Credits

• 2024 · Will & Harper as Self
• 2022 · Weird: The Al Yankovic Story as Ben Scotti
• 2022 · Studio 666 as Darren Sandelbaum
• 2021 · MacGruber as MacGruber
• 2021 · America: The Motion Picture as Abraham Lincoln (voice)
• 2020 · Scoob! as Shaggy Rogers (voice)
• 2020 · Have a Good Trip: Adventures in Psychedelics as Self
• 2020 · The Willoughbys as Tim Willoughby (voice)
• 2020 · Who Wants to Be a Millionaire as Self - Contestant
• 2020 · Flipped as Jann Melfi
• 2019 · The Laundromat as Doomed Gringo #1
• 2019 · Good Boys as Max's Dad
• 2019 · Booksmart as Doug
• 2019 · Alien News Desk as Drexx Drudlarr (voice)
• 2019 · The Lego Movie 2: The Second Part as Abraham Lincoln (voice)
• 2018 · The Shivering Truth as (voice)
• 2018 · A Futile and Stupid Gesture as Doug Kenney
• 2017 · Tour de Pharmacy as French Gendarme
• 2017 · The Gong Show as Self - Judge
• 2016 · Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping as Bagpipe Player
• 2016 · Keanu as Hulka
• 2015 · The Ridiculous 6 as Will Patch
• 2015 · Moonbeam City as Red Cunningham (voice)
• 2015 · She's Funny That Way as Joshua Fleet
• 2014 · Car Matchmaker with Spike Feresten as Himself
• 2014 · Tim and Eric's Bedtime Stories as Will
• 2014 · 22 Jump Street as 'Previously' Narrator / Football Announcer (voice) (uncredited)
• 2013 · Life of Crime as Marshall Taylor
• 2012 · The Watch as Sergeant Bressman
• 2012 · Rock of Ages as Mitch Miley
• 2011 · A Good Old Fashioned Orgy as Glenn
• 2010 · MacGruber as MacGruber
• 2009 · Sit Down Shut Up as
• 2008 · Saturday Night Live Weekend Update Thursday as
• 2006 · Beerfest as Otto
• 2006 · Campus Ladies as
• 2005 · SNL Digital Shorts as Will
• 2005 · SNL Digital Shorts as
• 2004 · Around the World in 80 Days as Policeman
• 2002 · Clone High as Abe Lincoln / Narrator (voice)
• Future · The Four Seasons as
• 2025 · Win or Lose as Coach Dan (voice)
• 2024 · Sausage Party: Foodtopia as Jack (voice)
• 2024 · Thelma the Unicorn as Otis (voice)
• 2024 · Bodkin as Gilbert Power
• 2023 · Scott Pilgrim Takes Off as Older Scott Pilgrim (voice)
• 2023 · Scott Pilgrim Takes Off as Even Older Scott Pilgrim (voice)
• 2023 · Krapopolis as Campos (voice)
• 2023 · Aliens Abducted My Parents and Now I Feel Kinda Left Out as Cyrus
• 2023 · Strays as Doug
• 2023 · Ruby Gillman, Teenage Kraken as Gordon Lighthouse (voice)
• 2023 · Clone High as Abe Lincoln (voice)
• 2023 · Gremlins: Secrets of the Mogwai as Warden (voice)
• 2023 · That '90s Show as Kiefer
• 2022 · The Afterparty as Self
• 2021 · Sweet Tooth as Richard Fox / Pubba
• 2021 · HouseBroken as Shel (voice)
• 2021 · Drunk Bus as Fred
• 2021 · The Great North as Wolf Tobin (voice)
• 2020 · Dwell as Self Help Book Narrator
• 2019 · Extra Ordinary as Christian Winter
• 2019 · I Think You Should Leave with Tim Robinson as
• 2019 · I Think You Should Leave with Tim Robinson as Old Man on Plane
• 2018 · Craig of the Creek as Barry (voice)
• 2017 · Night of Too Many Stars: America Unites for Autism Programs as Self
• 2017 · Future Man as CASSIN-E
• 2017 · No Activity as Dirk (voice)
• 2017 · Tim and Eric Awesome Show Great Job! Awesome 10 Year Anniversary Version, Great Job? as Will Grello
• 2017 · Michael Bolton's Big, Sexy Valentine's Day Special as Michael Fulton
• 2015 · Don Verdean as Pastor Fontaine
• 2015 · We Bare Bears as Additional Voices (voice)
• 2015 · Close Up with The Hollywood Reporter as Self
• 2015 · 7 Days in Hell as Sandy Pickard
• 2015 · Staten Island Summer as Griffith
• 2015 · The Last Man on Earth as Phil Tandy Miller
• 2015 · Get Squirrely as Cody (voice)
• 2015 · Saturday Night Live: 40th Anniversary Special as Self / Greg Stink
• 2015 · Star vs. the Forces of Evil as Tyler / Hunter / Chet / Blue Helmet Kid (voice)
• 2014 · Horrible Bosses 2 as Derelict (uncredited)
• 2014 · Apartment Troubles as
• 2014 · Sock or Hat? as Self - Contestant
• 2014 · Michelangelo & Lincoln: History Cops as Lincoln (voice)
• 2014 · Late Night with Seth Meyers as Self
• 2014 · The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon as Self
• 2014 · Off Camera with Sam Jones as Self
• 2014 · The Lego Movie as Abraham Lincoln (voice)
• 2014 · Run & Jump as Ted
• 2013 · Rick and Morty as Eugene Michael Piss / Pissmaster (voice)
• 2013 · Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2 as Chester V (voice)
• 2013 · Nebraska as David Grant
• 2013 · Grown Ups 2 as Male Cheerleader (uncredited)
• 2013 · Drunk History as Edwin Booth
• 2013 · Coffin Dodgers as Voice
• 2012 · Gravity Falls as Tyler Cutebiker (voice)
• 2012 · That's My Boy as Phil
• 2012 · Comedy Bang! Bang! as Chet Barnsider
• 2012 · The Immigrant as Will
• 2012 · Tim and Eric's Billion Dollar Movie as Allan Bishopman
• 2012 · Lab Rats as Eddy
• 2012 · Lab Rats as Eddy/Teddy
• 2012 · Lab Rats as Eddy / Cheddy
• 2011 · Allen Gregory as Stewart Rossmyre
• 2011 · Up All Night as Reed
• 2011 · Bob's Burgers as Mr. Grant (voice)
• 2011 · Bob's Burgers as Kurt (voice)
• 2011 · Audio Tour as
• 2010 · Conan as Self
• 2010 · The Women of SNL as Greg Allman / Various (archive footage)
• 2010 · Skott & Behr as
• 2010 · Saturday Night as Self
• 2009 · The Slammin' Salmon as Horace the Lone Diner
• 2009 · The League as Chuck
• 2009 · The Cleveland Show as
• 2009 · Brief Interviews with Hideous Men as Subject #72
• 2009 · Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs as Joe Towne (voice)
• 2009 · Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen as Self - Guest
• 2009 · Saturday Night Live: The Best of Amy Poehler as Various (archive footage)
• 2009 · Parks and Recreation as Kelly
• 2009 · Late Night with Jimmy Fallon as Self
• 2009 · Fanboys as THX Security Guard #4
• 2008 · Young Person's Guide to History as
• 2008 · Young Person's Guide to History as Monsieur Bouffant (The Frenchman)
• 2008 · The Life & Times of Tim as Chipper (voice)
• 2008 · Baby Mama as Scott
• 2007 · The Brothers Solomon as Dean Solomon
• 2007 · Flight of the Conchords as Ben
• 2007 · Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Great Job! as Pall Willeaux
• 2007 · Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Great Job! as Will Grello
• 2007 · Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Great Job! as Dr. Reid Tamaranda
• 2007 · Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Great Job! as J.J. Pepper
• 2006 · 30 Rock as Paul L'astnamé
• 2006 · 30 Rock as Tomas
• 2001 · Ghost World as (uncredited)
• Future · Sunny Nights as Marvin Martin
• Future · Coyote vs. Acme as Kevin Avery
• Future · Expiration Date as Robin
• Future · Kinda Pregnant as
• 2006 · Demetri Martin: These Are Jokes as Self
• 2005 · How I Met Your Mother as Randy
• 2005 · American Dad! as Jesus Christ (voice)
• 2005 · American Dad! as Butt Insurance Salesman (voice)
• 2005 · American Dad! as Charlie Greenfield (voice)
• 2005 · American Dad! as Security Guard (voice)
• 2005 · American Dad! as Mayor Woodside (voice)
• 2005 · American Dad! as Convention Attendee (voice)
• 2005 · American Dad! as Firefighter Henry Watkins (voice)
• 2004 · Drawn Together as Kirk Cameron (voice)
• 2000 · Aqua Teen Hunger Force as Alien (voice)
• 1993 · Late Night with Conan O'Brien as Self - Guest
• 1993 · WWE Raw as MacGruber
• 1989 · The Simpsons as King Toot (voice)
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as Self - Various Characters
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as Self - Cameo (uncredited)
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as Self - Host
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as Self
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as MacGruber
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as Robotron
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as Referee
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as Department Head
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as Band Member
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as Wolf Man
• 1975 · Saturday Night Live as Husband